PAPER TIGER: 3 STARS. “low-key crime drama about family, greed and sacrifice.”
SYNOPSIS: In “Paper Tiger,” a new crime thriller starring Miles Teller, Scarlett Johansson and Adam Driver, and now playing in theatres, an engineer and his ex-cop brother get tangled up with the Russian mob.
CAST: Miles Teller, Scarlett Johansson, Adam Driver. Directed by James Gray.
REVIEW: “Paper Tiger” is a character driven, low-key crime drama about family, greed and sacrifice.
When we first meet engineer Irwin Pearl (Miles Teller) he’s living a quiet suburban New York life with wife Hester (Scarlett Johansson) and kids Scott (Gavin Goudey) and Ben (Roman Engel). With Scott on the way to college, an opportunity from Irwin’s brother and former cop Gary (Adam Driver) to make some extra cash is welcome.
Gary wants Irwin to consult on the Gowanus Canal, a 2.9 km long polluted canal in Brooklyn. “This could be the perfect opportunity for us to do something substantial together,” Gary says. “For the whole family. For the future.”
The too-good-to-be-true deal of course, has a hitch. By closing the deal, the brothers are now tied to the Russian mob. Despite Gary’s insistence that they are “paper tigers”—not as dangerous than they seem—Irwin’s family are soon placed in the crosshairs of the unpredictable mobsters. “We know where you live,” a Russian mobster warns Irwin.
Director James Gray’s first film in four years is a gritty, intimate affair. It’s not a big flashy thriller. Instead, it may be more accurate to call this a family horror, as Gray keeps the focus on the family and how they respond to a threat that is beyond their control.
The tension, save for a pulse racing late movie scene in a corn field that is as close to action as the movie gets, comes from Irwin’s helplessness to protect the thing he cares about most.
As Irwin, Teller leaves behind the cockiness that has typified many of his other roles to mine the deep vein of guilt he feels for putting his family in danger. From friendly family man to concerned father, his performance anchors the film.
Underused, Johansson still brings steely determination tempered by fear. Driver, as the overly confident Gary, has the film’s flashiest role, but it’s Teller who carries the dramatic heft.
“Paper Tiger” isn’t for audiences concerned with closure. A tense shoot out sequence provides enough of a dopamine hit to allow us to call this a thriller, but in the film’s final moments Gray opts for a more literary approach that softens the expected emotional wallop.

