Facebook Twitter

EBENEZER: 3 STARS. “serviceable but dull adaptation of a classic.”

SYNOPSIS: In “Ebenezer” Johnny Depp stars as Mr. Bah Humbug, a wealthy and misanthropic businessman who hates Christmas in this new big screen remake of the classic Charles Dickens novella “A Christmas Carol.” “I wish to be left alone.”

CAST: Johnny Depp as Ebenezer Scrooge, alongside Rupert Grint, Andrea Riseborough, Sam Claflin, Daisy Ridley, Tramell Tillman, Ian McKellen. Directed by Ti West.

REVIEW: There’s a meta moment in “Ebenezer.” Johnny Depp, playing a man transformed after a surveying of his life, says, “I’m not the man I was.” It’s hard not to imagine those words also have meaning for the actor, who makes his return to big budget films after several years of controversy.

He comes back to theatres in “Ebenezer,” a familiar, darkly gothic tale set in early Victorian London. It’s Christmas Eve, a time of celebration for everyone, except miserly businessman Ebenezer Scrooge (Depp) who waves away any hint of Xmas cheer with a brisk, “Humbug!”

If he had his way he says he would boil anyone who wishes him a Merry Christmas in their own pudding and bury them with a stick of holly through their heart.

As the rest of London prepares for the big day, Scrooge is haunted, first by the ghost of his late business partner Jacob Marley (Ian McKellen), now a tortured soul draped in heavy chains forged by the sins he committed in life.

“I failed to honor the time I was gifted,” he says.

Marley tell his old friend that he will be visited by three spirits, the Ghosts of Christmas Past (Andrea Riseborough), Christmas Present (Tramell Tillman) and Christmas Yet to Come (Robert Strange), who will offer him a chance at redemption. “Listen to them,” he says. “Learn from your mistakes. Change, Ebenezer.”

Reliving moments of the past that saw him hardened to those around him, experiencing the melancholy moments of present day and seeing the bleak future that awaits him if he doesn’t see the light, Scrooge must search to see if the flame of humanity still flickers in his heart.

One of the most adapted stories in film and television history, “A Christmas Carol” has served as the source material for hundreds of versions, from the 1901 short “Scrooge; or, Marley’s Ghost” and 1992s “Muppet Christmas Carol” to Bill Murray’s “Scrooged” and the 1951 Alastair Sim classic.

So, is “Ebenezer” different than all the other versions? The advertising tagline thinks so. “If you think you know his story, think again,” it reads and it does feel distinctive from most takes of the Christmas tale.

Structurally, the screenplay by Nathaniel Halpern wanders from Dickens. Dickens originally planned “A Christmas Carol” as a ghost story and a study of inequality in Victorian life but Halpern flips the script. He gives Marley more backstory and develops Scrooge’s childhood trauma as a source of his hardheartedness, but it’s in his treatment of Dickens’s social justice themes that the screenplay makes its biggest moves.

In Halpern’s version Scrooge’s distrust of the poor is attributed to shady charity workers who line their own pockets with donations meant for the underprivileged. It fundamentally changes the core of Dickens’s story of systemic neglect of society’s less fortunate.

Director Ti West, however, is faithful to Dickens’s ghost story. Best known for making horror films like the “X” trilogy and “The House of the Devil,” he amps up the gloomy, atmospheric horror with jump scares, some unsettling moments and creepy imagery in the three ghost sequences. It’s more eerie than actually scary, but the ghosts are effectively portrayed.

Despite Halpern’s changes, “Ebenezer” is a serviceable, if a little dull, adaptation but it serves more as a vehicle for Depp to essay another in his long list of oddball characters rather than a radical reimagination.

Depp delivers a performance, buried under an inch of prosthetic makeup, that sits on the shelf alongside his work in “Sweeney Todd,” “Pirates of the Caribbean,” “Dark Shadows” and “Sweeney Todd.” It’s eccentric, emotional and comedic, a showcase for Depp’s unique touch.

His take on Scrooge veers toward sentimentality as he is exposed to lost loves and missed opportunities at creating relationships that could have given him the kind of joy he only otherwise found in collecting money from “those too poor and too blind to settle their debts.”

As the movie winds toward the end credits, it’s impossible to watch Depp’s performance without seeing a parallel to the actor’s major studio comeback and Scrooge’s search for redemption. The success of the film may well depend on whether the Ghost of Tinsel Town Past visits audiences this weekend.

Even with Depp’s off kilter lead performance, “Ebenezer” is a tad dull in its midsection, but even a ho hum version of this story supplies emotional moments. The Christmas setting, the suggestion that no matter who we are, or what we’ve done, it’s never too late to let our humanity shine, make this a time-honored story despite this middling presentation.


Comments are closed.